the
following
verse:
"0
you
who
believe,
obey
God
and
His
Messenger
and
the
people
of
authority
from
among
you,
."
The
beginning
of
the
verse
which
commands
us
to
obey
God
and
His
Messenger
contradicts
the
obedience
of
a
transgressor
ruler
who
legalizes
what
is
forbidden
in
Islam.
When
we
obey
this
Ruler,
we
would
be
disobeying
God
and
His
Messenger.
Despite
all
of
this,
Muslim
masses
and
scholars
took
the
end
of
the
verse
and
overlooked
its
beginning.
They
ignorantly
or
deliberately
identified
the
obedience
of
God
and
his
Messenger
with
the
obedience
of
the
unjust
rulers.
Thus,
when
a
transgressor
ruler
kills
innocent
Muslims
because
they
are
opposed
to
his
un-Islamic
behavior,
his
action
would
be
justified.
Muslim
in
his
Sahih
(part
12,
page
40)
reported
the
following:
"Abdullah
Ibn
Omar
came
to
(his
cousin)
Abdullah
Ibn
Mutee
when
the
Battle
of
‘Al-Harrah’
took
place.
(In
this
Battle,
the
sacred
City
of
the
Prophet
was
defiled
by
Yazeed’s
army
and
its
righteous
people
were
massacred.)
Spread
the
cushion
for
Abu
Abdul-Rahman
(Abdullah
lbn
Omar),
Abdullah
Ibn
Mutee
said
to
his
aides.
But
Ibn
Omar
said
to
him:
1
did
not
come
here
to
sit
down;
I
came
to
report
a
hadith.
I
heard
the
Messenger
of
God
saying:
‘Whoever
stands
in
open
disobedience
(of
a
caliph
to
whom
he
owes
obedience)
will
meet
God
on
the
Day
of
Judgment
lacking
any
excuse.
And
whoever
dies
owing
no
allegiance
to
a
caliph,
dies
in
a
pre-Islamic
state.’
By
reporting
this
hadith,
Ibn
Omar
was
trying
to
prevent
his
cousin
Ibn
Mutee
from
revolting
against
Yazeed,
urging
him
to
give
allegiance
to
the
wicked
caliph
who
demolished
the
Kaaba,
defiled
the
sanctity
of
Medina,
and
killed
the
lmam
Hussein.
This
shows
that
it
was
possible
for
a
hypocritical
government
to
cancel
Islam
gradually,
and
to
deviate
completely
from
the
path
of
the
Prophet
Mohammad.
Muaweyah
fought
the
Imam
Ali
in
a
war
in
which
45,000
Muslims
died.
And
the
Muslims
of
his
province
did
not
see
any
wrong
in
what
Muaweyah
and
they
had
done.
Yet,
the
Holy
Qur’an
(chapter
4,
verse
93)
declares
that
whoever
deliberately
kills
one
believer,
he
would
live
eternally
in
Hell.
The
consequence
of
such
attitude
by
the
Muslims
in
obeying
corrupt
leaders
is
that
an
un-Islamic
ideology
would
be
accepted
and
a
real
Islamic
ideology
would
be
rejected.
The
majority
of
the
Muslims
would
be
supporters
of
a
corrupt
ruler
and
ready
to
fight
his
opponents
who
see
in
his
words
and
deeds
the
antithesis
of
the
Islamic
teaching.
Yet
these
opponents
are
usually
afraid
to
defy
such
an
unjust
ruler,
because
he
controls
the
military
and
financial
power
of
the
nation.
Under
such
circumstances,
it
would
be
necessary
for
the
leader
of
the
opposition
to
do
what
is
beyond
his
ability.
His
followers
arc
less
than
a
minority
and
the
government
is
despotic,
determined
to
eliminate
any
opposition,
by
the
most
savage
means.
The
Imam
Hussein
realized
that
the
Omayyad
leadership
is
ready
to
change
the
Faith
of
Islam
and
to
abolish
it.
Nothing
would
be
prohibited
or
too
sacred
to
a
man
like
Muaweyah,
who
tried
to
kill
by
thirst,
the
Imam
Ali
and
his
army,
including
the
two
grandsons
of
the
Prophet:
Imam
Hassan,
and
Imam
Hussein.
The
Imam
Hussein
knew
that
Yazeed
was,
by
far,
less
religious
than
his
father
Muaweyah.
The
whole
nation
had
failed
to
stand
up
to
Yazeed.
They
succumbed
to
his
will
and
agreed
with
him.
As
deviation
and
revision
became
the
normal
way
of
life
in
the
Islamic
government,
the
future
outcome
became
obvious.
Revision,
deviation
and
regression
towards
the
pre-Islamic
state
would
continue
until
gradually
the
Faith
was
abolished.
Witnessing
the
failure
of
the
whole
nation,
the
Imam
took
upon
himself
to
do
alone
what
the
whole
nation
could
not
do.
One
man
carries
the
responsibility
of
the
whole
Muslim
World.
Should
he
fear
to
do
so,
the
continuity
of
Islam
would
be
in
a
serious
jeopardy.
The
continuity
of
Islam
needed
a
protector.
It
needed
the
unique